In the kitchen, Minnie was in a sugary panic. “Clara Cluck’s recipe said a pinch of nutmeg, but I used a pound !” she sighed, waving a handkerchief to clear a cloud of spice. Daisy, helping to frost cookies, just smiled. “Don’t worry, Minnie. The spirit of Christmas covers a multitude of baking sins.”

It was Mickey, Minnie, Donald, Daisy, Goofy, and all the kids. “We’re going caroling,” Minnie said. “And you’re coming with us.”

But one house on the hill was dark. Inside, Scrooge McDuck sat counting his money by candlelight, a scowl etched on his beak. “Christmas? Humbug! Just a day when people expect gifts instead of earning their interest ,” he grumbled. His only decoration was a single, dusty stocking with a hole in the toe.

Scrooge opened his mouth to refuse, but Pluto ran in, licked his hand, and dropped a new, un-chewed red ribbon at his feet. For the first time in years, Scrooge McDuck smiled.

“It’s me, Mr. McDuck. I think you have something of Donald’s.”

It was Mickey who figured it out. On the twelfth repeat, he noticed something. Scrooge, in every loop, was alone. No tree. No family. No laughter. And every time, he kicked away that tiny golden gear.

And Pluto? He finally got his wish. A giant, squeaky bone-shaped bow, which he wore proudly on his nose for the rest of the night.